Carly is a great singer, but she doesn't do anything on stage, other than lift her left hand to about waist high. She needs a band to work with.

Why does Syesha sing songs about sleeping with other people's husbands?

Brooke was, I thought, very solid. really nice arrangement as well.

Kady hit two of the flattest notes I've ever heard on American Idol ever.

So let's all hope that Danny gets sent home and that someone kicks him between the legs so he can remember he's a boy.

i dont' like any of the girls this season, my bet is that this year will be one of the guys.

i say bye to syessha and kady. danny and luke.

i really like the dude with dreds, he is getting better and now i am stuck on that song. i think it'll be my new ringtone.

my sister told me that david h. was a stripper ... hmmm, maybe that's why i like him ..... teehee

Hold on to your hat A3, he was a stripper in a mostly male bar...

My Jason made it through... Woo Hoo! And David Cook, I like him too. A3 I love that song too.

Now onto the girls...

Sorry to say that I am SO happy Danny's gone gone gone... Bye bye now...

Sad for Luke, I liked him he was a nice guy, but I thought he might go. I was surprised by Kristy and Asia'h, I thought Kristy would go...

Looking forward to next week.

Me too, now I only have to fast forward through Amanda - Kady was better, so was Asia'h.

did NOT know that little bit of info about david h. ... why didnt they put that in the "what america might not know about me" commercial ? yikes .. oh well, i'd tip him.

my broken heart ...Asia'h is gone. But she will record and sell millions. I predict it.

Danny boy is going back to his boy friend...OOPS did I say that out loud???
Luke as well.
My preferences on the chicks are now syesha and carly and Brooke is a close third.

Guys, David H and David A. ALso still like Michael as much as any - but american idol i dont know about yet...

I was at my favorite coffee hangout yesterday and I heard some people talking about AI.

They said "They" aren't even considering any of the female singers this year and that "they" are already writing songs to fit David H and I couldn't hear the other name . I don't know is "they" are but I was assuming it was the writers that write the song for the finale/Idol winner.

I hope it was David Cook or Jason cos I like them. I think I like them even more than Michael now.

I like Brooke... she's my favorite

2 hours of Idol tonight. WooHoo!

Good show.
David A was awful - he is in fact human.
Carly rocked. Michael was great. Brooke is SOOO REAL.
CHikezie was good too.
Liked David C ALOT. He is growing on me.
AManda is just plain not in the same league. Although sheis different.
Say goodbye to Christy Lee Cook - she was like on meth or something singing 8 days a week like a 2 beat country song. REALLY WIERD>

I loved Carly, Brook and David Cook last night.

I liked Jason but last night's performance wasn't as great as last week's.

For the first time in my AI viewing career I voted. For Jason. Cos I want him to stay in till next week so he can redeem himself with another great song.

I agree with you Nab. I said goodbye to Kristy last night.

I'm in Austin and didn't get to see it, I was out takin pitchers of the state capital I think tivo had my back tho.

I predict someone with the name of David will make the top 3 in guys.

Can't for the life of me understand why David H is going home and Amanda didn't even make the bottom 3

Too bad I didn't get to see the show last night, but there's no way David C or Jason is more talented than David H. Amanda, Kristy and Ramiele should have went home ahead of David H too

that is so weird to me. i don't get it. oh well. i didnt see the show and didnt vote. and personally, i think david arch. "rigged' his mess up.

MY THOERY STANDS...
Similar artists in style dilute their votes amongst eachother.
syesha and asaia'h
david h and david a
krisy lee and teh other white chick (alaina?)
soon it will be between jason and michael
or amanda and carly
My prediction for final two - DAvid A and Carly (michael will be a close third) then syesha 4th

I didn't think David A and H were of similar style, but I believe what you said is true. Amanda is the Sanjaya of '08

I think part of the problem is the "fan clubs" and it being a popularity contest. Since there's no cost to cast your vote by phone you can dial for the full two hours and register as many votes as you can get through. If you had to pay for those calls, or you were only allowed one vote, it might be a little more fair. People would make that vote count.

I was shocked that Kristy made it through. I thought David H was ten times better than she was. And please... enough of Amanda...

I thought David Cook was the best that night.

yep.
what i meant by style was , i guess more genre than anything. Young white crooner vs young(er) white crooner (mellower too) and nice looking black haired big smiles guys. I personally believe Hernandez is a better vocalist, Archuletta is just pure heartthrob for the kids (who are the voting ones).
Cant believe is wasn't KRispy Lee Cooked. that went home.